Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style, and tone. 4. As Twain shifts his tone, his point of view became more negative. The meaning of Mark Twain's Two Ways of Seeing a River is the idea that once you gain knowledge, and life experiences, one may have a different way of looking at something. 1A. Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions Posted on February 18, 2015 March 6, 2015 by kearamcniel No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style , … 1 0. Two Ways of Seeing a River by Mark Twain What the first responder gave you are known as similes which are basically the same as metaphors (in the way that they compare two things) except they use like or as. Which is it? Change ). 1B. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style, and tone.. A. What is gained by the apparently deliberate decision to use rhetorical questions only toward the end? In fact, it could refer to all of us! In Paragraph 1, his point of view of the river was majestic and beautiful like his writing. Explain. ( Log Out /  Which is it? 3. Why, or why not? How effectively does it perform the function intended? However, once we’ve experienced everything and started maturing, things started to become more realistic. In the first paragraph, Mark Twain states that the Mississipi in his eyes is no more graceful as he saw it when steamboat is new to him. 2. How is Twain’s shift in tone related to the change in point of view? 1.2 It changes from the third sentence of paragraph 2 by stopping eulogizing the river. His opinion was directed to the danger and utility of the scene instead of its romance and beauty which he talked about in the first paragraph. He wonders if the doctor just sees the medical aspect of a pretty woman when he (the doctor) looks at her. I had lost something which could never be restored to me while I lived. 4.What is gained by the apparently deliberate decision to use rhetorical questions only toward the end? We stop questioning things, stop theorizing, and started experiencing less. Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style, and tone. Overall, in “Two Ways of Seeing a River”, Mark Twain addresses the importance of understanding the extent of the merits of what people have. He describes the sight as beautiful and graceful. How about the latter part of paragraph 2? The danger is manifested and his description of the river based on his feelings disappeared. Yes, the same fact can be interpreted different ways with different opinions, being objective does not necessary mean that the author is negative or positive. No, it is a metaphor which the author refers the doctor to himself. The memoir recounts his early days as a steamboat pilot on the Mississippi and then a trip down the river … “Two Ways of Viewing the River” is a short excerpt from Mark Twain’s autobiography written in 1883 that compares and contrasts Twain’s point of view as a Mississippi River boat pilot. ... even those people who haven't read the essay can also give their opinions. It makes the reader compare it with their own lives. Metaphors can be vague and open to interpretation. Reading questions: 1.1 In paragraph 1, the author likes and eulogizes the river. The essay is an expressive contrast that explains how Twain’s views change as he becomes more familiar with the river. Two Ways of Seeing a River (1883) This passage is excerpted from Mark Twain’s 1883 book Life on the Mississippi, in which he shares his experiences as a river steamboat pilot and explores the many facets of the great river. How effectively does it perform the function intended? and i'm sorry but i can't answer your question because i'm not familiar with that piece. The shift is important to the Author’s contrast because we really understand how his views of the river have changed since his first experiences with it. Are your answers to 2 and 2A related to point of view? 2B. The rhetorical conclusion keeps the readers thinking about the subject of his writing. Is this part of the writing closely enough related to the major contrast to justify its use? Is the paragraph 1 primarily objective or subjective? His first description is about not knowing the river very well. 2. Paragraph 2 is objective because it’s more knowledgeable and based on experience. Why, or why not? Does the author permit himself to engage in sentimentality? 1A. What is the point of view in paragraph 1? 1C. What is the point of view in paragraph 1? A.How about the latter part of paragraph 2? It’s sort of romantic, but hints at how… ( Log Out /  two ways of seeing a river Jocelyn-Guzman In the story of” Two Ways Of Seeing A river” was a personal and creative essay. 1B. In paragraph 2, he revisits the idea that the beauty of the river was lost and explains why that happened. B.Is this part of the writing closely enough related to the major contrast to justify its use? They were mostly positive adjectives showing that the author has a positive image towards the scene. Having a girlfriend. However, listening to the same songs, it loses its beauty. 5.Specifically, what changes in style accompany the shift in tone and attitude? Why, or why not? If so, how? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Twain’s strategic organization reinforces his idea about decaying beauty. ...Analysis on Two ways of seeing a river by Mark twain Now when I had mastered the language of this water and had come to know every trifling feature that bordered the great river as familiarly as I knew the letters of the alphabet, I had made a valuable acquisition. ( Log Out /  Where do you find a second comparison or contrast? We discussed that when we’re young, everything seemed to be fun. 1. Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions Posted on February 18, 2015 by lizzyvieyra2015 No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style , … The method of organization that Twain uses in this selection is time order because he described the way he saw and experienced the river in a sequence The central theme of the reading is two ways of seeing the rivers that the shift is moving on one way to anther. Though his tone was hinting that he was not satisfied with his situation, but his content is purely objective. Two Ways of Seeing a River by Mark Twain What the first responder gave you are known as similes which are basically the same as metaphors (in the way that they compare two things) except they use like or as. 2.Where, and how, does it change in paragraph 2? Twain compares his view of the river shifting from beautiful to practical with a doctor seeing blushes as a disease rather than a “visible charm.”. Get answers by asking now. What is the point of view in paragraph 1? Did he gain or lose by  shifting from experience to knowledge? 1D. Throughout his writings, the author did engage sentimentality. Explore the possibility, citing TWO examples, of being able to retain both the “rapture” and “usefulness.”. "Two Ways of Seeing a River" is an excerpt from the end of Chapter Nine of Mark Twain's autobiographical work "Life on the Mississippi," published in 1883. Listening to a good music for the first time’s always enjoyable. Parallelism is pretty effective in my opinion. ... Are your answers to 2 and 2A related to point of view? 1. It brings up the difference between these two ways. No, it also referred to himself. He used the first paragraph to state his original situation, the second paragraph on later thoughts on the same situation, this first post the comparison. Metaphors can be vague and open to interpretation. Both lost romance in their work/surrounding because of the practical issues they have to face. What is the most noteworthy feature of syntax in paragraphs 1 and 2? But as times goes by and practical stuff such as making a living starts to get into the way, the passion of life will eventually wear off. The comparison is made within itself because Twain compared and contrasted how two people of different occupations, one being a doctor, view rosy cheeks. Something external, a doctor and his patient has nothing to do with a river practically, they only connect in a symbolic way. Is the paragraph 1 primarily objective or subjective? The questions make the reader think about elaborate what Twain is trying to describe in the story. Why, or why not? What is the point of view in paragraph 1? What is the point of view in paragraph 1? 3.Why is the shift important to the author’s contrast? Essay on Responses to Question 1 and 4 on “Two Ways of Seeing a River” on page 481 of Model for Writers 1. ( Log Out /  Subjective, in a sense that his used adjectives to describe the scene according to his own feelings and emotions. writing a novel: when you finally ran out of patience and ideas and writing becomes boring and annoying. If you limit the time you listen to the artist, you can still enjoy his or her music. 1.3 It serves as a transition. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style, and tone. How does Twain use organization to assist in the overall comparison? 3. In the first paragraph, the author describes the river with his… But the paragraph is more about how he know the river differently and he like the river more. In what way? I dont wanna date anymore. In the beginning of paragraph 1, Twain gives us a little hint about how he now feels about the river. 2. The author starts to worry about the potential danger of the river. Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions Posted on February 20, 2015 by veronicamora2015 No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style , … This part of the writing is, in my opinion, closely enough related to the major contrast to justify its use because in both situations, Twain addresses how one’s point of view can change with more experience. In the first paragraph, he was describing the sunset with all sorts of fancy words and a vivd list of imagery, but in the second paragraph, he used quotation marks to build the effect that as if he was saying the paragraph. The work’s expressive purpose is evident throughout. It is a reminder to stop and enjoy the beauty of nature. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. After his claim, Twain fully describes an impressive view of the sunset at Mississipi. He was looking at the facts behind the beauty in a sarcastic tone. 3.What is the most noteworthy feature of syntax in paragraphs 1 and 2? In my opinion, these few paragraphs are pitch perfect as well as technically masterful. In paragraph 2, instead of praising the beauty of the sunset scene, the author criticized the usefulness of the elements that formed the scene. The relationship lost all the magic. The Point of view in paragraph 1… Therefore, he saw all the aspect of beauty and the aesthetic nature of the river from first sight. Because he went so into detail about the sunset in the first paragraph, a reader can clearly understand his theme about decaying love. Questions 1 and 2 -- Twain is using the example of a doctor to illustrate his own situation with the river. He spoke from himself changed into speaking of facts. If not, what restraints does the author use? 3C. In this piece from his 1883 autobiographical book Life on the Mississippi, American novelist, journalist, lecturer, and humorist Mark Twain ponders the losses and gains of life and its countless experiences. How does Twain’s shift relate to the central theme of the reading? 1. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. Another example could be listening to an artist. It took more effort to fully comprehend what he meant. What is the point of view in paragraph 1? Two Ways of Seeing a River Posted on February 18, 2015 by morourke2015 No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style , and tone . Point View, Style and Tone. If so, how? It becomes dull because I already know how the song goes and it would lack the sense of not knowing and excitement. Just as when a person speaks, their word choice varies with their mood. In the third paragraph, where the author compared a lady and a doctor’s relationship to the river and his. It notices the readers that the author is going to… 1E. His theme was about his attitude change towards the same river during the course of time. I personally enjoy the first description of Twain's "Two Ways of Seeing a River". 1F. Still have questions? 3A. Having a girlfriend at the beginning of a year is great but dating her for so many years but it starts to suck from seeing her everyday and talking to her threw all the fights. The point of the writing is to compare and contrast the 2 point of view and the shift in paragraph 2 was needed to do so. C.List other vocations (. Then to reinforce his point, he made an analogy, which is a second comparison, to contrast his situation with one that we will be familiar of. Is the comparison/contrast made within itself, with something external, or both? Being an artist: that a person can appreciate the beauty around him/her and can also make a living with his/her talent. It was published in 1883 in Mississippi, by Mark Twain. The river itself is clearly a metaphor, as to what it is a metaphor for is unclear to me. 1. The meaning of Mark Twain's Two Ways of Seeing a River is the idea that once you gain knowledge, and life experiences, one may have a different way of looking at something. Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions. Explain. As you read, consider his masterful use of language as he re-flects on his changing relationship with the river. Explore the possibility, citing TWO examples, of being able to retain both the “rapture” and “usefulness.” “What is also in my life, that I once saw beautiful but when I experienced it too much, lost its beauty?”, 2. But perhaps with a lot of money. Explain. To show how the author has changed with his attitude towards the same river over years, and also show what the author lost. To create the imagery, he uses very bold and concrete adjectives that form that instance in your… Discuss how, if at all, Twain’s contrast might be used to show parallels to life itself–e.g., differences in the idealism and attitudes of youth and maturity. I start to memorize the whole song and it starts to get boring to me . Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Twain’s theme of the river losing its beauty, his tone and point of view also lose its beauty in the second paragraph. Since he is using first person narrative, his emotions emerged with his description and it is unavoidable since narrating in first person involve opinionated wordings. In the story of “ Two Ways Of Seeing A river” was a personal and creative essay. Specifically, what changes in style accompany the shift in tone and attitude? In paragraph 1, Twain’s poetic language mirrors his view on the river. -the point of view is that the… ( Log Out /  A.Is the comparison/contrast made within itself, with something external, or both? marriage: when daily life problems (bills, household chores etc) overwhelms the romance The shift of the river becoming a beautiful to a dull experience is important to portray the two different scenarios to the reader. Yes, how a doctor lost appreciation to his patients compares to how the author lost interest in the river. Change ). I did not find that there was a topic, but more of a theme creating flow and imagery. Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions March 6, 2015 jasonhinton2015 Leave a comment No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials in point of view (and attitude), style , … If so, how could it have been avoided without damage to his theme’s development? Starting with talking about seeing the river first instead of the beauty. I believe that Mark Twain’s first way of seeing a river is the better of the two. A.If not, what restraints does the author use? ( Log Out /  ( Log Out /  Twain’s point of view suddenly changes in paragraph 2 because he describes when one day he didn’t see the same beauty of the river that he saw when he had first seen the sunset. Where, and how, does it change in paragraph 2? Then, the shift in Paragraph 2 when his point of view became realistic, like his writing, became easier to understand. If so, how could it have been avoided without damage to his theme’s development? Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions. B.Are your answers to 2 and 2A related to point of view? Two Ways of Seeing a River: Reading Questions No selection could better illustrate the intimate relationship of several skills with which students of writing should be familiar, especially the potentials inpoint of view (and attitude), style, and tone. But I had lost something, too. Why is the shift important to the author’s contrast? His point of view in paragraph 1 is how “majestic” the Mississippi River was when he was still new to steam boating. Explain. 3B. movies: when logic and common sense destroy the fantasy of the super hero legacy or the romance fantasy However, once I started knowing more about how to play it, I start playing more competitive and start to become open to challengers. After that, he goes into detail explaining his most memorable experience with the sunset. Sleeping: resting while living in “the dream land”. If so, how? 2A. Read Mark Twain’s “Two Ways of Seeing a River.” Now when I had mastered the language of this water and had come to know every trifling feature that bordered the great river as familiarly as I knew the letters of the alphabet, I had made a valuable acquisition. In what way? List other vocations (at least 3) in which you assume (or perhaps know) that the beauty and romance eventually give way to practical realities; state briefly, for each, why this hardening should be expected. Two Ways of Seeing a River Ruthrashineel MARK TWAIN Two Ways of Seeing a River (1883) This passage is excerpted from Mark Twain’s 1883 book Life on the Mississippi, in Which he shares his experiences as a river steamboat pilot and explores the many facets of the great river. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. 3. Two Ways of Seeing a River Questions. He described what he observed from a … He questions whether experience and knowledge is more rewarding than the vivid perception of things and the … Does the author permit himself to engage in sentimentality? Jade Fox An Analysis of “Two Ways of Viewing a River” “Two Ways of Viewing a River” by Mark Twain is a work that causes the reader to think twice about how he or she appreciates everyday things. His use of words became plain compared to the first paragraph. Sometimes when you run around trying to get things done and stressing, it helps to just stop for a moment and enjoy a sunset or maybe even stop to smell the roses. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. 1A. 2.How does Twain use organization to assist in the overall comparison? Explain. Usually as teenagers, we will have different visions and dreams for life. How does Twain’s shift relate to the central theme of the reading? Does all his medical knowledge negate the pleasure of her beauty. It helps the author organize his details and provide an order that helps the readers to connect one point to the other.